The iPhone Air is doing so badly it is destroying an entire {industry}

When you’ve been following my writing in any respect — thanks, for those who do — you are in all probability conscious that I have been in opposition to the iPhone Air since earlier than it was launched. I respect and even admire the completed product on an engineering degree — however it’s at all times felt like a telephone looking for a market, relatively than one constructed to fulfill any demand. In reality it is usually believed that Apple’s actual objective is laying the foundations for its first foldable.

Gross sales of the Air have reportedly been unhealthy, nicely behind the iPhone 17 lineup. Extra lately, indicators have pointed to the debacle having industry-wide ramifications, ones which might final for years. The information for tech firms is bitter — in the end, although, it ought to be a win for us shoppers.

The fallout from the iPhone Air

The place Apple goes, others observe

Apple’s whims have guided the smartphone {industry} for nearly 20 years now. Among the giants that originally scoffed on the iPhone both misplaced their status or exited the enterprise fully, equivalent to Nokia and RIM. Those which have maintained any affect are those that developed — as Frank Herbert as soon as put it, “Adapt or die, that is the primary rule of survival.” The strongest success story has arguably been Samsung, which selected to repeat the iPhone nearly instantly, and has completed nicely sufficient that Apple generally imitates again. We would not have 6-inch iPhones as commonplace if units just like the Samsung Galaxy Notice hadn’t paved the way in which.

In keeping with DigiTimes, although, three main Chinese language manufacturers are actively selecting one other path within the wake of the iPhone Air. Xiaomi has allegedly jettisoned a “true Air mannequin;” Oppo and Vivo have halted comparable tasks. This follows experiences of Korea’s Samsung not solely chopping manufacturing of its present Air clone, the Galaxy S25 Edge, however interrupting any work on an S26 Edge.

The importance of not one however 4 firms veering off should not be underestimated. It takes a big dedication of time and sources to launch any smartphone line, so producers will usually stick issues out even when the chances are in opposition to a (main) hit. ASUS stored producing compact Zenfones nicely after Apple deserted the iPhone mini, as an example, and Samsung retains promoting Plus variations of its Galaxy S telephones regardless of customers preferring base fashions or an Extremely. If these Plus units are doing nicely sufficient to justify their existence, that claims quite a bit about Samsung’s evaluation of each the Edge and the iPhone Air.

All that is going to have repercussions not simply on company funds, however on the form of the smartphone {industry}. You may safely assume that the ultra-slim class will keep area of interest for some time, until maybe Apple’s second-gen Air — rumored for 2027 — fixes all the problems that tanked the primary. I am undecided that telephone makers will substitute it with something completely different, however it does appear cheap that they could swing improvement in the direction of the inevitable iPhone Fold clones, on condition that that product ought to be out in fall 2026.

The win for Joe Public

Bringing smartphones again to the actual world

Whereas the iPhone Air’s battery life turned out to be higher than feared, it is nonetheless inferior to any iPhone 17. Apple might have fastened that by equipping it with an energy-dense silicon-carbon battery, however determined as a substitute to play it protected and low cost through the use of conventional expertise — by no means thoughts that iPhone house owners have been clamoring for longer runtimes for the reason that starting. Equally, the Air is proscribed to a single, wide-angle digicam at a time when even the most affordable smartphones have two cameras, and triple-camera fashions are slowly changing into the norm.

These compromises would not matter a lot besides that the Air is definitely $200 costlier than the iPhone 17. You are paying extra for much less, until thinness, an A19 Professional chip, and a touch bigger display are one way or the other dramatic benefits for you. I do know individuals who love how gentle the Air is, however I’ve additionally heard many individuals agree that the Air ought to be priced at a reduction, not a premium. A $699 mannequin may’ve flown off the cabinets.

In my view, the Air represents one among Apple’s worst tendencies: its willingness to disregard public demand, particularly if it retains revenue margins up. Few if any folks outdoors the corporate have been clamoring for a thinner telephone. Certainly lots of people deliberately purchase thick, grippy iPhone instances, a few of them with stands or knobs that make them even bulkier. The Air appears like machine constructed to promote for as a lot as potential utilizing the fewest supplies potential — and/or assist refine a foldable iPhone, as I discussed earlier. I am undecided if that is true, however that is what it appears like.

If we’re fortunate, the Air is sending a message that this form of technique simply will not fly. You do, generally, must ignore the general public to create one thing progressive, pondering of the quote (mis)attributed to Henry Ford that if he had requested folks what they wished, they might’ve stated quicker horses. To actively disregard the largest calls for of your clients is hubris, nevertheless, and may solely proceed for therefore lengthy.

Some closing ideas

Finally, maybe, the iPhone Air could also be symptomatic of better points with the smartphone {industry}. Different firms have been content material to stint on high-demand options with none prompting from Apple, preferring upgrades which are cheaper to implement, but more and more marginal of their impression. Generative AI could also be a chief instance — whereas the tech definitely requires large datacenters, these datacenters have broad makes use of, and I’ve by no means heard anybody rave about how a lot they love textual content summaries or deleting rubbish cans out of photographs. It is not a leap to think about extra folks would like a telephone that lasts two days on a cost, or can really snap a portrait of their child graduating as a substitute of the complete stage.

The Air’s failure in all probability will not result in a golden period of extra responsive telephone makers, then. At this level, although, I am content material to see any slap on the wrist that forces makers to assume twice about what clients worth. It appears like Apple may even be listening — whereas the iPhone Fold is prone to be exorbitantly costly, rumors counsel the Air 2 could get two cameras.

I am really rooting for Apple to achieve the second-gen. I perceive that lots of people put numerous effort into the Air, and I’d like to reward that with my cash…so long as I really feel like my wants are revered. If the Air 2 continues to really feel like a grasping compromise, I am going to simply flip my consideration to the iPhone 18 and 18 Professional, a lot as present customers are specializing in the 17 and 17 Professional.